International Business Advisors
Posted by Manchester Trade 19 July 2010 at 10:25 AM 0 comments Labels: Africa, AGOA, MT in News, Team
The following are Manchester Trade’s suggestions to the US Administration and Congress for a proactive economic growth policy towards sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). A new approach is required for the United States to better relate to SSA aspirations. Important too is a need to recover lost ground from China’s increasing dominance of African resources and markets, India’s leadership of African countries in the World Trade Organization (WTO), and European Union (EU) success, through a subtle combination of trade pressure and aid incentives, in negotiating agreements with an increasing number of African countries. Particularly frustrating to US commerce is the discrimination US products face against the EU’s exports in SSA markets. Manchester Trade (MT) argues that the Obama Administration must develop a creative, proactive approach and move away from its reliance on once effective but now largely outdated policies as a way to boost its commercial presence in these emerging markets; and, more importantly, contribute to African growth through the promotion of regional integration.
Manchester Trade urges the US government to complement its current initiatives in agriculture, food security and climate change with an economic growth initiative aimed at unlocking the competitive potential of the fast-emerging SSA markets. MT recommends that the US put its support behind African-led initiatives to regionally integrate. Integration among economies will help overcome the challenges they face and help them to attain the economies of scale required to achieve world-class competitive production. Greater participation in increasingly sophisticated value chains is possible. Through more diverse economies, and greater intra-regional cooperation, Africa can reach a level of global competitiveness attained by Asian and Latin American countries that were in the same situation a few years ago. The US Administration must introduce new trade initiatives, trade capacity-building measures and incentives to American businesses interested in the region to make this potential a reality.
The colonial division of sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) led to the creation of 47 countries, almost all of which are too small to compete in the global economy and subsist at some of the lowest global income levels. A critical ingredient required in overcoming inefficiency and poverty is regional integration. As evidenced by the creation of more effective government institutions, economies of scale in production and infrastructure, and fostering development through the linking of small, land-locked economies, regional integration offers broad advantages.
A consensus is emerging that there needs to be a multi-Committee approach in Congress and an integrated approach from the White House and the development and financing agencies to develop a concerted approach among the key players.
Manchester Trade calls on the US government and Congress to provide a more comprehensive package of development and financing assistance to US-Africa programming initiatives than those that exist today.
RECOMMENDATIONS
Enhance US business opportunities in and with Africa
On March 24, the Subcommittee on Africa and Global Health of the House Committee on Foreign Affairs held a hearing on U.S. policy in Africa. The key witness was Assistant Secretary of State for African Affairs Johnnie Carson. Much of the discussion focused on human rights issues and whether the continent is experiencing a decline in democracy.
On the subject of trade, Ambassador Carson said that the Obama administration is working closely with African partners to maximize opportunities under the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA). He highlighted the President’s Entrepreneurship Summit, scheduled for April 26-27, which will bring together African businesspeople and explore ways to promote private sector growth.
Princeton Lyman, former ambassador to South Africa and a Senior Fellow of the Council on Foreign Relations, argued that regional economic communities (RECs) are important for the future growth of African states. He praised the progress made by the East African Community (EAC) and the Common Market for Eastern and Southern Africa (COMESA). He expressed concern that the European Union’s bilateral agreements with some states are threatening the unity of RECs. Ambassador Lyman also noted that African governments are siding against the United States in the WTO’s Doha negotiations, and he called for the U.S. to take a broader perspective on trade with Africa in the context of the WTO. He also called for more coordination on trade policy between government agencies such as State, USTR and USAID.
Witney Schneidman, President of Schneidman & Associates International, recommended that Congress grant tax credits to American companies that invest in AGOA eligible countries (excepting extractive industry investment). He quoted an estimate that for every $1 deferred in U.S. taxes, $5 in African income would be produced. In order to build support for African RECs, Dr. Schneidman also recommended that senior U.S. officials hold a joint annual meeting with the heads of the RECs.
Senator Wyden in his press release to the United States Trade Representative (USTR) requested to revoke the beneficiary status under the Africa Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA). This is recommended as the Ugandan Parliament is considering a Anti Homosexuality Bill that would imprison Ugandan citizens for being Lesbian, Gay, Bi-Sexual or Transgender. The the bill if turned into law will have the potential for death penalty in cases of "aggravated homosexuality." If Uganda passes this law, it would be a violation of AGOA provision which stipulates that the beneficiaries not to be involved in "gross violations of internationally recognized human rights."
Under AGOA Uganda has duty frees status for its exports to United States. Removal of this status will adversely affect its textile, handicrafts and cut flower industry among others. This year, Madagascar, Guinea and Niger lost their beneficiary status under AGOA. It would be an interesting development to see what the Obama Administration decides on Uganda.